CA court rules discounted phone bundled with wireless plan to be taxed at full price

Published on

CALIFORNIA — A California appeals court ruled, February 27, that customers who buy cellphones at a discounted price bundled with a wireless plan must pay taxes on the full price of the phone.

Plaintiffs in the case argued that it violates the Revenue and Taxation Code.

Tax on bundled phone plan

Alina Bekkerman, one of the plaintiffs in the case, says she bought a Samsung Galaxy S5 from Verizon for $249.99 as part of a bundled plan. The bundle required Bekkerman to sign a two-year wireless service contract with Verizon. 

Bekkerman paid Verizon sales tax reimbursement that was calculated based on her cell phone’s unbundled sales price of $599.99. 

Bekkerman along with three other Plaintiffs filed a complaint to stop the practice.

Is the bundled price a discount?

The disputed taxation comes from California Department of Tax and Fee Administration Regulation 1585, established in 1999. According to Justice Shama Hakim Mesiwala, it measures sales tax on a cell phone purchased in a bundled transaction by the cell phone’s unbundled, full price. 

One of the arguments Mesiwala along with Justices Harry Hull and Stacy Boulware make is that the agreed price for the cell phones is not a discount — the cell phone and the wireless services price is commingled.

“Where the cell phone is sold below wholesale cost, the vendor must be making up the difference through the sale of wireless services . . . . Obviously, if the vendor does not make up for selling the cell phone below cost through additional sales, it will be operating at a loss, and the laws of business say that it will not be operating very long,” states the court document.

Attorney Tony Tanke, who represents the plaintiffs, said they would appeal to the state Supreme Court.

To read the full court decision visit: https://www.courts.ca.gov/opinions/documents/C093763.PDF

RELATED: California gas tax increase effective July 1

spot_img

Latest articles

Insurance commissioner rejects State Farm’s emergency 22% rate increase

CALIFORNIA – California Department of Insurance (CDI) commissioner Ricardo Lara rejected, February 14, State...

Victorville Library giving away free tree for Earth Day

VICTORVILLE – The Victorville City Library is partnering with Neighborhood Forest to inspire youth...

California sues Trump over Musk’s ‘unconstitutional power’

CALIFORNIA – California Attorney General Rob Bonta announced, February 13, that California, along with...

CA lawmaker introduces bill to cap electricity rate hikes and ban safety power shut offs

CALIFORNIA – California State Senator Dr. Aisha Wahab (D-Silicon Valley) introduced, February 12, SB...

More like this

Insurance commissioner rejects State Farm’s emergency 22% rate increase

CALIFORNIA – California Department of Insurance (CDI) commissioner Ricardo Lara rejected, February 14, State...

Popular craft store closing 500 locations nationwide – laying off 209 warehouse employees in CA

CALIFORNIA – Joann announced, February 12, that it was closing 500 stores nationwide, including...

FAIR Plan receives $1 billion bailout – law allows insurers to recover 50% from CA property owners

CALIFORNIA – California Department of Insurance (CDI) commissioner Ricardo Lara approved the FAIR Plan’s...